It might seem like a great idea to mix leftover paints to save money or achieve the perfect color, but not all paints play well together. Mixing different brands, types, or finishes can lead to uneven textures, inconsistent colors, and durability issues. Here’s everything homeowners need to know about paint mixing—straight from the experts at Randall’s.
1. Can you mix paints from different brands?
Technically, yes — but it’s not recommended unless the paints have similar formulations.
Different paint brands use unique combinations of resins, binders, and pigments. Mixing incompatible formulas can cause:
- Clumping or separation
- Uneven drying
-
Reduced adhesion or peeling
- Color inconsistency
If you must mix brands, test a small batch first before applying it to a large surface.
2. What about mixing different finishes (like matte and semi-gloss)?
Mixing finishes changes both sheen and performance. For example:
- Mixing flat and glossy paint will create a mid-sheen finish (similar to eggshell or satin).
- However, the result may not be uniform or reproducible across the wall.
It’s better to select a finish you like from the start. Check out Randall’s collectionsfor a full range of matte, eggshell, satin, and gloss finishes.
3. Can I mix latex and oil-based paints together?
No — these two types are incompatible.
-
Latex paint is water-based.
- Oil paint uses solvents as a base.
When combined, they won’t blend properly and can separate or form a thick, unusable mixture. Always stick to one paint type per surface for best results.
4. Is it safe to mix paints if they’re both water-based?
Yes, if they’re both water-based latex or acrylic and made by reputable brands, they can usually be mixed.
Still, keep in mind:
- Colors may shift once dry.
- The final finish might not match the original paint’s durability.
Use proper mixing tools and blend thoroughly for consistency.
5. Will mixing paints affect color accuracy?
Yes. Even small differences in formula or base tint can produce unexpected results.
- Two “off-whites” from different brands may dry to different shades.
- Pigments may react differently under certain lighting.
If you’re trying to create a custom color, Randall’s experts can color match accurately using professional tinting equipment — available through our services
6. Can I mix leftover paint from previous projects?
Only if:
- The paints are the same type (both latex or both oil)
- The same finish (both matte, for instance)
- Both are in good condition (not separated, clumpy, or expired)
Stir well and test on a small area first. If the texture or color looks off, it’s best not to use it.
7. What happens if I mix incompatible paints?
Problems can include:
- Uneven drying or cracking
- Peeling or flaking over time
- Sticky or gummy texture
- Unpredictable color changes
These issues can be costly to fix, often requiring sanding and repainting.
8. Is there a professional way to blend paints safely?
Yes — professional painters use measured tinting techniques rather than mixing full cans.
At Randall’s, we use calibrated color systems to create custom blends with consistent tone and finish. Visit our servicespage or contact our paint specialists to ensure a precise mix.
9. Can I tint one brand’s paint with another brand’s colorant?
It’s not advisable. Paint brands use proprietary colorant formulas, and combining them can lead to inaccurate shades and uneven application. Stick with one manufacturer’s tint system for guaranteed consistency.
10. What should I do if I already mixed two paints?
If you’ve already mixed them:
- Stir thoroughly for several minutes.
- Apply a small test patch and let it dry fully.
- Check color uniformity, sheen, and texture.
- If it looks uneven or feels sticky, don’t apply it to large surfaces.
Randall’s experts can help you troubleshoot or recommend a matching alternative.
11. Where can I get advice or custom color mixing help?
At Randall’s, we offer:
- Custom color matching and tinting services
- Expert product recommendations for compatibility
- Professional painter connections via our Painter Order Form
- Friendly in-store advice — visit or reach out via our Contact Us
Mixing paints can be tempting, but it’s best to leave color formulation to the pros. Combining different brands or finishes may save time in the short term but often leads to unpredictable results.
At Randall’s, we make it easy to find the perfect paint type, color, and finish — no mixing guesswork required. Explore our collectionsor stop by for personalized advice from our paint experts.